Talk:Elixir of Life: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Move discussion of undead vs unliving to talk page) |
Tag: Undo |
||
| (27 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Undead is not the same as unliving == | |||
Undead is not the same as unliving | |||
Undead: Creatures risen from dead, i.e., all Necropolis creatures | Undead: Creatures risen from dead, i.e., all Necropolis creatures | ||
Unliving: Creatures that are animated via magic, i.e., Gargoyles are golems | Unliving: Creatures that are animated via magic, i.e., Gargoyles are golems | ||
:This seems only a statement, which has already been covered in [[Undead]] and [[Non-living]] articles. Or was there some kind of link to this article? –[[User:Kapteeni Ruoska|Kapteeni Ruoska]] ([[User talk:Kapteeni Ruoska|talk]]) 08:33, 12 July 2016 (CEST) | : This seems only a statement, which has already been covered in [[Undead]] and [[Non-living]] articles. Or was there some kind of link to this article? –[[User:Kapteeni Ruoska|Kapteeni Ruoska]] ([[User talk:Kapteeni Ruoska|talk]]) 08:33, 12 July 2016 (CEST) | ||
:: I second this. Undead is not the same thing as unliving and the article presents them as equivalents which might be very misleading. People might take this as a fact and might not check the respective sections covering the two topics. I suggest removing the sentence entirely. | |||
:: --[[Special:Contributions/93.91.51.153|93.91.51.153]] | |||
: | ::: The description is redundant when it says, "Undead or unliving," as all Undead creatures ''are'' unliving. | ||
::: --[[Special:Contributions/Ibraesil|Ibraesil]] | |||
:: | :::: Based on a comprehensive study I have modified [[Undead vs Unliving|the classification]] to include three distinct groups without subgroups: | ||
:::: They are the '''once-living''', the '''never-living''', and the '''living'''. | |||
:::: --[[user:imahero|imahero]] 05:29, 5 October 2016 (CEST) | |||
Latest revision as of 14:26, 6 November 2024
Undead is not the same as unliving[edit | hide | hide all]
Undead: Creatures risen from dead, i.e., all Necropolis creatures Unliving: Creatures that are animated via magic, i.e., Gargoyles are golems
- This seems only a statement, which has already been covered in Undead and Non-living articles. Or was there some kind of link to this article? –Kapteeni Ruoska (talk) 08:33, 12 July 2016 (CEST)
- I second this. Undead is not the same thing as unliving and the article presents them as equivalents which might be very misleading. People might take this as a fact and might not check the respective sections covering the two topics. I suggest removing the sentence entirely.
- --93.91.51.153
- The description is redundant when it says, "Undead or unliving," as all Undead creatures are unliving.
- --Ibraesil
- Based on a comprehensive study I have modified the classification to include three distinct groups without subgroups:
- They are the once-living, the never-living, and the living.
- --imahero 05:29, 5 October 2016 (CEST)